H2O Seafood and Sushi- East Islip

H2O Seafood

It was fun dining at the former Beachtree Restaurant in East Islip, but it was definitely time for a change. Beachtree was the first restaurant my family went to when we moved to East Islip, I remember walking over with my sister and eating there while we were taking a break from moving into our new home. Watching the construction from my house was torture because I was so excited to have such a nice restaurant in East Islip. I’m hoping this inspires new restaurants to open on Main Street in East Islip.


H2O Seafood and Sushi Review

H2O Seafood H2O Seafood


Top:  First up we ordered Clams on the half shell, it was very fresh and went well with the cocktail sauce.

Bottom: The Tuna Tartare was incredible. The tuna was mixed with fresh avocado, topped with crispy fried shallots and sat in a lemon soy sauce.

H20 Seafood H2O Seafood


Top: The Montauk Roll was amazing, it was creamy and had the perfect amount of spice. In the roll it had spicy tuna, avocado, tempura, lobster, yuzu mayo and eel sauce.

Bottom: The Triple Threat Roll was my favorite. Its very simple ingredients but the flavor profile was still very good. In the roll it had spicy salmon, tuna, yellowtail and the cilantro that added a clean finish to the roll.

H2O Seafood H2O Seafood Dessert

Top: I ordered the Tear Drop which was a layered chocolate hazelnut mousse and almond sponge cake, with a chocolate crunch bar and vanilla ice cream. One of my favorite dessert combinations is chocolate, hazelnut and banana so I obviously enjoyed this dessert.

Bottom: Rich ordered the Peanut Butter Banana Split.  It was our favorite, it included both vanilla and chocolate icecream, bananas, crispy peanut butter and chocolate ganache.

Have any reccomendations for restaurants you would like me to review? Comment Below! Don’t forget to follow me on Facebook and Instagram @baniandchai!


A| 166 W Main Street East Islip, New York 11730

T| (631) 277-4800

You may also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *